May 28
History which is taught in Malaysia is BULLSHIT !!
Lets start with Form 4 teks book.. It has 5 chapters about Islam.
What to do ??
Too bad, this is a ’so called’ Islam country although the circular does not state that.
So in the beggining of those chapters, they have a glance on all the religions. So first we have Hinduism, then Buddhism which looks normal according to history.
Now, when they talk about Christianity, its written
Agama ini dikatakan diasaskan oleh Jesus Christ…
That means it is said that Christianity was initiated by Jesus Christ.
So indirectly saying that its juz said la.. Maybe not true wan…
Now, this is what written bout Islam…
Agama in telah DIWAHYUKAN kepada Nabi Muhammad s.a.w…
Thats means this religion is directly given to Muhammad. CONFIRM !!
Now the point is… This is history, which is taught in schools…
In Form 1, we are taught that history must have a reason, facts, and prove.
Since its taught in Malay its, sebab dan akibat, bukti yang kukuh.
So I questioned a teacher who taught this.. I said I remember I studied in Form 1 that to make something a history, the fact must be true and must have proof… Then I asked her… What proof do you have that diwahyukan is true ?? Did anyone see ?? How can it appear in History text books…??
I saw her face changing.. And she tried to cover…
Guess what answer she gave me ??
She said, the poems which is in Al-Quran is so sweet and its only recited by Muhammad at that time. And no other man on earth could do the same. Nice answer ah..??
So juz because the poem cannot be made by any other man..
Therefore, it is considered as history and they say its true and its a religion..
So i’m gonna create a lots of poem and see if I can make my own religion..
How stupid is tat answer..??
Then I said, yea ok.. But what proof..?? Too bad she cannot cover and finnaly she said..
OK..OK.. If you say this is not history, why is it accepted in world history and why people in Europe can accept it ??
I immidietly asked her, HAVE YOU EVER READ THE ISLAM HISTORY ??
She was like erm…erm… Got…I read before…
I said there is Islam history and its accepted in western countries but the content is not diwahyukan and stuff… Its about how they conquer other lands for Islam..
Finnaly she goes, nevermind Andrew. I think you better go read more history.
And I said OK..
This is the level of our country’s education. Which is a total crap…
Changing the history and INDIRECTLY teaching Islam religion to coming generations…
6 Comments so far
Leave a comment
It has been a bullshit for years and the best part is everyone knows that it is a bullshit.
Incorrect history on Islam will not get greater with lies and deceit, no matter how much perfume it is added to it. Tell the truth and the learning of history will be interesting - but then again, to do that in Malaysia is going to be a miracle itself. But probably that is why we are blessed with Internet and Cable TV, I guess.
[The world will be a better place to live if Malaysia does that.. Hmm..at least we have sumthing to know the truth]
hehe. what you’re studying isn’t ‘history’, but ‘government propaganda’…..though that does call into question whether there’s any other type, since history is written by the winners.
live in here,you must bear with it..i suppose..
[No, if I live here.. I should try making it better, not just keeping quiete..]
the only reason is the writer believes that Christianity is a religion which was created by the irresponsible prophet wannabe, not Jesus P.B.U.H..talk about comparative religion, no offense but I think you know that the al-quran is still genuine, never being modified till now, so the copy we got in hand is original.. unlike bible (wrong translation is one of its flaws)
and yeah, your teacher gave a stupid answer. couldn’t agree more with that..
[Yea, but the writer has no rights to do so because there are believers like me studying it. Its an indirect way to teach Islam to the nation. How do you know your Quran is still genuine. Did you see ?? Did you see when it was given to Muhammad ?? So its the same as well... Don't say by transalating can cause the Bible to lose its meaning...]
see bro. many tahfizs (definition for people who memorized the qoran) during Muhammad S.A.W time memorized the quran in their ‘head’. After the prophet passed away, unfirtunately many of them die during warfares and due to that caliph Uthman decided to have the quran written and compiled.
what we recite right now does not contradict what being recited in arab saudi (ni Makkah) for a long time ago and even now..reasons: the quran is still in arabic language, unchange. Plus, caliph uthman era is only few years after the prophet passed away..so why question its authenticity?
Al-Quran consists only god’s words.. (firman allah if we call that in Malay btw)
[Yea, i get that. But how do you say that Bible which is read here contradicts with the Bible in the U.S]
i didn’t say that.
[Haha.. Ok.]